The cook-along works for someone who roughly knows what they're doing. But a genuinely novice cook who doesn't know what "fold in" means, or can't tell if oil is hot enough, hits the step-by-step instructions and is still lost. We added tip cards on the recipe preview and Train quizzes on the homepage — but both happen before you start cooking. What the cook-along actually needed was contextual help inside the step itself: a tooltip on "fold in" that opens right there, without leaving the screen. That's the version I'd build next.
The curated chef model is the right call for quality — structured, reliable, detailed guidance. But it creates a ceiling on what you can cook. A Gen Z user who finds a recipe on TikTok or gets one from their mum can't bring it into the app. In a follow-up version I'd explore importing and adapting external recipes into the Yes, Chef! format — keeping the tip cards and guided structure while opening up the content library.
Running unmoderated tests on UserTesting.com taught me something I didn't expect: writing precise task instructions is a design skill. In moderated sessions, participants could ask questions when confused. On UserTesting.com they interpreted tasks differently and took paths we hadn't anticipated. The tasks that generated the most useful data were the ones written most precisely. That's a lesson about communication I've carried into every research activity since.